Kool-Aid Dye Results

Alright, folks.. here’s what I found, and why I started doing this.

Quick breakdown- While the general consensus is that you can dye wool (or any protein fiber) there’s a myriad of ways that are presented on the internet on how exactly to do it. I have a bunch of curly curly fleece that’s going to need some serious color soon so I decided to investigate. But.. something bothered me- one site had mentioned dry yarn and wet yarn. Their assertion was that one would produce more vibrant colors than the other. So.. yeah, I had to test it.

To do the test, I decided on four distinct sample runs- for the dry a simple 15 minute and 30 minute application. For the wet, I let them soak for the 15/30 minutes, followed by a five minute soak in the dye. All test yarns were done with Lion Brand Alpine Wool in their Vanilla color, and all were between 5 and 5 and 1/4 inches. The dyes were all prepared the same way- one packet of powder in a 20 oz. washed and dried soda bottle, plus a quarter teaspoon of distilled vinegar and 1 cup of warm water (warm to aid in the mixing of the powder into the water) These bottles were shaken vigorously until there were no visible traces of powder in the bottom of them, and then re-agitated right before they were sampled.

The tests themselves were run in half pint mason jars (I’m a woman of many talents), with approximately 1/4 cup of solution. This.. might have actually been a problem. Some sites I have read on the subject have suggested that it’s possible that the dye can be interfered with by having too much pigment trying to into too few fibers… at least that was my understanding.

After their soaks of appropriate length, they were wrapped in plastic wrap and put in the microwave for 30 seconds. In almost all cases (I’ll discuss the exception below), after the first 30 seconds the water was running clear so I rinsed them and placed them to dry. Then I mounted them to a foam board.

The point of  my post is not to give instructions on the proper way to do this- there are plenty of tutorials available on the Internet and I am by no means an expert. I simply wanted to answer this one question that was bothering me- is it true that dry yarn produces a more vibrant color? Cause boy howdy, if it does that’s the way I want to go- I like bright and work almost exclusively in bright colors.

So.. what did I find?

Here, in a nutshell:

Kool Aid 01Kool Aid 02 Kool Aid 03

These are most of the colors I was able to get a hold of- I still have packet of Pink Swimmingo and Rock a dile Red left over from the summer’s limited edition run. I’m loathe to use the Rock a dile Red.. it has sentimental value, you guys! Anyway I suspect that it’s not going to be tremendously different from say, the Strawberry up there. All pictures are cropped and rotated a bit, and were taken in natural light- there has been no retouching save for the cropping and rotation. Yes that’s my turrible handwriting and graphing fails- except for Orange.. I had a little helper for that one.

My results and conclusion-

In general, yes you DO get a more vibrant color with dry- however this should be taken with the following observation- for many colors it simply didn’t matter and there *were* cases where the wet yarn produced the more intensely colored variant. For many cases, the color differences were very minor between ANY of the four samples and in a significant number of them there was no perceptible difference.

For those cases where things seemed a little off (Ice blue Raspberry Lemonade comes to mind)- I’d like to redo the test on those at a later date to confirm my findings. One test is simply not enough for a solid data pool, but I’ve got to have my focus elsewhere for the next few weeks, so I won’t be able to replicate the experiment for a bit. I’d also like to expand the whole thing a bit and actually have some fun with color combinations. I’m going to see if I can find a reasonable source for tangerine Kool-Aid, which apparently is good for toning down some of these other colors.. makes me wonder if Orange would work as well.

Oh, as mentioned above- Grape and Purplesaurus Rex were the solutions that just wouldn’t run clear for me. Honestly, when I pulled the yarn out to microwave it, the samples looked gray and not purple-ish at all. I’d read it was a dingy purple color and I have to say I agree, but the color did resolve itself a bit better than gray, so I didn’t press to figure out how to get that blue back into the fiber.  In short if you’re looking for a super violet color, you’re not going to find it in grape- I’d suggest maybe some Wilton colors (which I have a few of those so maybe I’ll do a future post with those as a focus.)

In conclusion, it seems worthwhile to further explore some color combinations and perhaps rerun a few of the more quirky results in this experiment. I’ll admit I wasn’t as hard and fast on the timer with the first few samples and that might have made a significant difference. Oh and if you made it this far, you rock!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: